The Consequences of Bad Advice in Retirement

Fee-only Retirement Income Planners, Calgary

Age 65 is too old to be following bad advice.

Based on the advice from their bank, this couple converted all of their respective RRSPs into RRIFs. They had rather large RRSPs and now that they were converted to RRIFs this meant that they were required to take a minimum income payment every year going forward. Being over 65, they both qualified to start taking their OAS, so they had started that as well. It seemed reasonable, but here's the problem. They then decided to sell their business, which required them to declare all of the proceeds of the sale as income in the same year.

The unexpected consequence was a huge tax bill because their income suddenly spiked temporarily. They also lost all of the OAS to the clawback for one full year because their incomes were above the OAS $75,000 threshold. That alone was over $14,000 in lost income. 

All of the above happened because of bad advice and poor planning.

And, all of it could have been easily avoided. It's the law of unintended consequences and it will bite you every time. Every financial decision you make will have an impact on other parts of your financial situation. For example, deferring CPP and OAS will result in you getting more money from it, however, getting more money could also put you into a higher tax bracket and result in paying more income taxes and experiencing an OAS clawback. In this case, getting more can actually result in getting less in the long-term.

Here are some other examples.

Conventional wisdom suggests that you should wait until age 71 to start taking income from your RRSPs so that you can take full advantage of the tax deferral process. Once again, this can have a negative impact on your taxable income and cause you to pay more taxes and possibly have an OAS clawback. Receiving money in one hand and then having to give it back with the other hand is not a sound financial decision.

Most people will have numerous sources of income in retirement. You may have an RRSP, TFSA, LIRA, LIF, Group RRSP, Defined Benefit Pension, Defined Contribution Pension, CPP, OAS, GIS, Stocks, Bonds, Stock options, RSUs, Employment income, Business Income, Retained earnings, etc.

If you are married, you can multiply that by 2. It's not unusual for people to have up to 20 different sources of income in retirement. The more sources you have, the more coordination is required in order to ensure you get the most cash flow, in the most tax-efficient manner and have complete confidence your money will last. It's been my experience that most people forfeit a lot of income from poor planning and are paying too much tax. This can easily be avoided with pre-retirement and post-retirement planning.

Here are a few key principles to keep in mind when it comes to organizing your retirement income. 

1. There are no cookie-cutter plans. We rarely see two couples with exactly the same circumstances. It is so important that you do not make major decisions about any one aspect of your income sources. For example, taking CPP at age 60. This may be a good idea for some people and for others, it will make sense to delay until age 70.

2. As a rule of thumb, you will want to use your less flexible and less tax-efficient sources of income first. In this case LIRAs, RRSPs, and government benefits can form the base of your income in the early years and TFSAs and non-registered sources later in retirement.

3. Guaranteed sources of income need to form the base of your cash-flow planning. This can be a LIF, government benefits, DB pension, Annuities. Your total income need in retirement might be $80,000, however, how much do you require to meet your basic living needs? It may only be $40,000. If that is the case, we would recommend that you cover that base from guaranteed income sources. The rationale being that if the markets are performing poorly, you will not want to take out money while your accounts are down in value. We all quickly forget that the markets do not go up in a straight line, as they have done for the past 11 years since 2009. There may be years of negative growth or little growth. 

4. Inflation. Most retirees underestimate the impact of inflation on their income needs. If you need $80,000 per year to meet your needs today, that could mean about $100,000 11 years from now and $120,000 in 20 years from now if we have 2% inflation. Are your investments and income plan designed with an inflation buffer built-in?

5. Retirement income must be sustainable, predictable, tax-efficient, flexible, and perpetual. You need to have a strong degree of confidence that it will be there each year for the rest of your life and your surviving spouse's life. You are planning for the next 30+ years so take the time to do it right.

At Langford Financial Inc., we specialize in fee-only planning for those transitioning into retirement. Our plans start at $1000.

You can learn more about our fee-only and all-inclusive planning services by clicking here.

Retirement Income, Investment & Tax Planning,

Willis J Langford BA, MA, CFP

Nancy R Langford CRS


Langford Financial Inc. is an independent financial planning and investment practice specializing in fee-only retirement income planning for the nearly and newly retired. Nancy holds a Certificate in Retirement Strategy and Willis is a Certified Financial Planner® 


Share This Post:

Related Posts

Latest Testimonial

Partnering up with Willis & Nancy for our retirement goals has been the best decision we have ever made.

Previous agents or companies only seemed interested in obtaining funds from us with no further support or contact.

Willis & Nancy have worked with us at least twice a year to make sure we are set up for success. They have been able to provide us with a visual picture of where we currently stand financially in order to determine if we are ready to retire or need a few more years. It has alleviated the stress we were feeling about retiring and having no idea of what that would look like.

For the first time, we feel confident that when we make that final decision we will be able to continue on and be financially and mentally prepared.

Deb & Garry

Debbie & Garry
Long-term Clients

Contact Us

Questions? Comments? Call us today at 587-755-0159 or fill out the form below:

Have Questions? Call Us Today At

Call Us

Join Our Newsletter